Request a free site audit

Interested in offering ad free site memberships?

Life news: I got a dog


Notes on dynamic meters

In my notes on membership, I referenced a few types of meter experimentation, like testing different meter rules based on content or geography. Also more complex tests, like changing rules based on referral or whether the user has an ad blocker enabled.

These meter approaches are essentially deterministic. Given a set of conditions the meter should respond in the same manner. These rules are most familiar to users who experience them on sites like the New York Times or Washington Post. While user data may be used in marketing and retention algorithms, it is not generally used in meter logic.

The Wall Street Journal was reported in February to have launched a personalized meter for the first time “after years of testing”:

Non-subscribed visitors to now each receive a propensity score based on more than 60 signals, such as whether the reader is visiting for the first time, the operating system they’re using, the device they’re reading on, what they chose to click on, and their location (plus a whole host of other demographic info it infers from that location).

Nieman Lab

This INMA article has more details on the WSJ classifier.

Scandinavian publishing house Schibsted has also explored this approach. And as the Lab notes, the Financial Times has a long history of using user data to target offers.

Dynamic meters are becoming more feasible for small and medium publishers. Largely due to startup activity in this space. The dynamic meter space has a complementary idea in “Value Walls”, a term used to describe situations where a user may provide an email, follow a social media profile, or do some other valuable action to gain access to a restricted content or feature.

Piano, formerly TinyPass, has a tool called Canvas which can be used to lay out rules and potential actions/responses for a dynamic value wall. Here are some product images from their support site which help site managers lay out the business logic for their value wall using a graphical flow interface.

Startup Pico takes a CRM approach to the same problem, allowing site managers to design audiences and then set rules and membership offerings against each audience (like US vs non US or ad blockers vs non ad blockers).

In France, Google has funded Poool, operating in the same space as Pico and Piano.

Poool screenshot

Conversion tools like Optin Monster also have options to setup rules similar to the above, although without any paywall or checkout integration (focusing primarily on newsletter signups).

Google itself will also enter this space later in the year with Subscribe with Google, as will Apple, although neither company has indicated that it will support dynamic metering.

One open question: How will consumers respond to this price discrimination? News would not seem to fall under the protection of the Robinson-Patman Act. Assuming that we are able to deploy ethical algorithms that adjust price based on user data, what can we do to prevent the consumer from feeling gamed? While profit maximization may be greater due to price discrimination, I see some risk for consumer blowback as well. Perhaps because news companies have to meet a higher than average ethical standard.

Did you enjoy this post?

Signup to receive a weekly email containing my new posts, curated links, and book reviews.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.


Follow me on Twitter

Notes on newsletters

Following up my previous post on the membership business model for news, newsletters go hand-in-hand with successful audience acquisition & conversion into paid members.

Notes on the membership model for news

Penn State Campuses Lose University Recognition After Risk Analysis Review

The past, present, and future of making the WordPress Editor work for editors

Slope fields and community alignment


Capturing Shawmont Station before its $1,000,000 preservation begins – the oldest extant passenger rail station in America

Originally a 18′ by 36′ stone house (Wissahickon Schist), the structure wouldn’t have stood out from the other country homes in this part of Philadelphia, at the tip of the Manayunk Reach, situated at the end of today’s Manayunk Canal Towpath.

Testing WordPress Gutenberg on a high volume news site

Water, sand, and societal change

How Warren Buffett thinks about Berkshire’s newspaper holdings

At Berkshire Hathaway’s annual shareholder meeting, the Oracle of Omaha Warren Buffett shared a dismal outlook on print media.

EverQuote and patent medicine

In a thread begun October 2016, Washington Post technology director Aram Zucker-Scharff tweeted about the shady advertising practices of EverQuote, a Boston-based startup. Since then these ads have become prolific on the web (and nearly as prolific are Aram’s tweets documenting the malfeasance).

The other Hershey (and its railroad)

Cuban town Camilo Cienfuegos might be one of the least expected places to find remnants of America’s great 20th-century industrial expansion – that is, until you hear its pre-revolutionary name: Hershey.

Receive a weekly email with newly posted content

  • About one email per week
  • Includes original posts, curated links, and book reviews

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

Send this to a friend